Indianapolis to New York in September 2026

Dated one-way fares from Indianapolis to New York in September 2026. Use the calendar to see which days are cheaper.

Lowest this month $110

Highest this month $134

Sample fare $110

Airports IND–LGA

Ad. Ticket links are affiliate ads. We may earn a commission if you book. Advertising disclosure

September 2026 price calendar

From $110 · up to $134

Mon

Tue

Wed

Thu

Fri

Sat

Sun

11 $117 12 $126 13 $126 14 $126 15 $126 16 $126 17 $134 18 $117 19 $113 20 $113 21 $110

New York NYC

$110

Sep 21, 7:48pm · 20h 12m · 1 stop

IND → LGA · Frontier Airlines

New York NYC

$117

Sep 11, 7:48pm · 16h 2m · 1 stop

IND → JFK · Frontier Airlines

New York NYC

$117

Sep 18, 7:48pm · 25h 11m · 1 stop

IND → LGA · Frontier Airlines

This page is only September 2026 on the Indianapolis to New York route. Open the full route if you want the next months side by side.

Prices move as seats sell. Confirm the live itinerary before you book Indianapolis to New York in September 2026.